Why Suvs Aren't Necessarily Safer Than Sedans In A Crash

Gorodenkoff/Shutterstock

SUVs proceed to predominate nan automotive landscape. They're mostly much applicable than sedans acknowledgment to their boxy shapes, allowing for a larger interior volume. They look safer, too; nan higher, commanding seating position provides amended visibility, and nan sheer size gives a psychological reassurance to nan passengers. And they are so safer for their passengers erstwhile progressive successful multi-vehicle collisions. In different words, if a sedan and an SUV collide, nan SUV's passengers are much apt to survive.

Case closed, then? Well, multi-vehicle collisions are only a portion of each types of roadworthy crashes. And though they're nan astir common, they lead to less fatalities than different roadworthy accidents. What happens erstwhile you deed an immovable entity (or a cyclist) pinch an SUV? And what astir rollovers? In cases for illustration these, SUVs are overmuch little safe than sedans. From longer stopping distances to higher centers of gravity, SUVs person their ain gremlins that tin frighten nan lives of passengers and different postulation participants. That's why this article will person a person look astatine each information aspects of SUVs utilizing existent information from reputable organizations and investigation papers.

fotoreporter_112/Shutterstock

You've astir apt heard "You can't hit physics" measurement excessively often successful car reviews. Yes, it's stale, but besides 100% true. There's a measurement called Static Stability Factor (SSF), which determines really top-heavy a conveyance is. The look that determines this facet is SSF = T/2H. T is nan way width (the region betwixt nan near and correct wheels), while H is nan tallness of nan halfway of gravity. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administrtation (NHTSA), nan SSF of astir rider cars is from 1.3 to 1.5, while for SUVs it ranges from 1 to 1.3. The little worth intends that SUVs are much top-heavy successful general, which increases their rollover probability.

The statistic support this claim. According to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), 34% of nan caretaker deaths successful SUVs successful 2023 were rollover-related. For cars successful general, including little rider vehicles, nan number was overmuch lower, astatine 21%. For single-vehicle crashes, 24% of nan deaths successful SUVs were rollover-related, while successful cars it accounted for conscionable 16%.

To beryllium fair, rollover deaths successful some cars and SUVs person been decreasing since 1978, chiefly acknowledgment to nan implementation of modern stableness systems. However, SUV drivers look to beryllium little alert astir their safety. A 2017 observational study published by the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) found that SUV drivers are much apt to thrust without a spot belt. And, unsurprisingly, many fatal rollover crashes impact victims being ejected from nan vehicle.

Y_carfan/Getty Images

According to Newton's Second Law of Motion, objects pinch higher wide transportation much momentum. So, naturally, heavier vehicles besides transportation much momentum, meaning they require much power and abstraction to extremity — and SUVs are heavier than sedans. For instance, nan guidelines Honda Accord pinch nan 1.5-liter four-cylinder turbocharged motor weighs 3,239 pounds. The CR-V pinch nan aforesaid motor is arsenic overmuch arsenic 3,614 pounds. So it shouldn't beryllium astonishing that SUVs are not coming among the cars pinch nan champion braking times.

Sure, automakers usually put bigger brakes and wider tires connected SUVs to counteract nan added weight. But sedans still person somewhat shorter stopping distances. In a 2021 Consumer Reports study, luxury midsize cars needed 128 feet to decelerate from 60 to zero mph, while luxury midsize SUVs needed 134 feet. You mightiness deliberation that six-foot quality isn't massive, but there's much to nan story; astatine nan 128-foot mark, nan SUV will still beryllium moving and carrying momentum forward. And since SUVs are heavier and recreation faster during braking, they will deed immoderate entity pinch greater force.

Although automakers person improved SUV braking systems importantly complete nan years, a caller study by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Mobility Initiative recovered that SUVs and pickup trucks still person inadequate braking. This is only worsened successful electrical SUVs, which accelerate to 60 arsenic accelerated arsenic sports cars but don't extremity astir arsenic well.

It's undeniable that SUVs fare amended successful head-on crashes pinch rider cars. So, yes, you are safer successful your SUV successful a multi-vehicle clang than successful a sedan. However, SUVs are worse successful single-vehicle crashes than sedans. Rollovers are nan superior logic here, but hitting an immovable entity — for illustration a span pillar aliases a character — is measurement much vulnerable successful an SUV.

Again, it's each owed to nan higher momentum of heavier vehicles. Even astatine nan aforesaid speed, SUVs transportation much kinetic power than sedans, which results successful heavier crashes. In different words, sedans will deed a tree, lamppost, aliases wall little difficult than SUVs, resulting successful a little likelihood of terrible wounded aliases death. SUVs' longer stopping distances and higher halfway of gravity don't thief nan situation, only serving to summation nan probability of decease and superior injury.

There's besides a important quality betwixt unibody and body-on-frame SUVs. Unibody SUVs person a chassis that's akin successful building to sedans pinch information features for illustration crumple zones, while body-on-frame SUVs person a ladder chassis for illustration pickup trucks. So, unsurprisingly, a 2014 clang fatality study published connected PubMed reveals that passengers successful unibody SUVs were astatine an 18% little consequence of decease than passengers successful body-on-frame SUVs. The latest information continues to support this conclusion, arsenic location are nary body-on-frame SUVs that person earned nan highest Top Safety Pick+ grant from IIHS. It seems for illustration ruggedness is much of a trading term, not a information rating. That being said, successful general, mini crossover SUVs still person more caretaker fatalities per mile.

Lost_in_the_Midwest/Shutterstock

One of nan astir chilling aspects surrounding nan risks of progressively ample SUVs is kid deaths. A study from the NCBI noted that these vehicles (as good arsenic pickup trucks) are much apt to deed kids while moving successful reverse down their driveway. While doesn't mention nan specifics down these circumstances, it's not excessively difficult to presume that unsighted spots could play a awesome role.

SUVs person overmuch larger unsighted spots, often hiding kids from nan driver's position — and blind spots keep getting larger, too. Notably, a 1997 Honda CR-V enabled drivers to spot 68% of nan area wrong 32.8 feet successful beforehand of nan car. Meanwhile, nan current-gen exemplary decreases nan viewable area to conscionable 28%. And it's not conscionable Honda's bestseller — SUVs fared importantly worse crossed nan board. The latest Accord, connected nan different hand, provided a importantly higher 60% viewable area, which is only a 5% driblet complete its 2003 model.

Of course, nan biggest logic for this is nan progressively taller hoods of nan latest SUVs. They are truthful precocious that you tin fresh aggregate kids successful nan unsighted area and they will beryllium wholly invisible to nan driver. Because they beryllium higher from nan ground, SUVs besides person worse back-over visibility. Fortunately, each caller cars sold successful nan U.S. from 2018 onward are equipped pinch a backup camera, which mostly solves that peculiar issue. If beforehand cameras were mandatory successful caller SUVs, these frontover unsighted spot problems mightiness not beryllium rather arsenic worrying.

Warchi/Getty Images

Kids aren't nan only demographic affected by SUV size creep — it besides endangers cyclists and pedestrians. In a 2020 study, nan IIHS looked into 79 crashes successful 3 municipality areas successful Michigan and recovered that SUVs caused much terrible injuries than rider cars, including sedans, erstwhile they deed pedestrians. A meta-analysis of respective studies by the NCBI besides recovered that SUVs are disproportionately much vulnerable for pedestrians and cyclists.

Those pesky unsighted spots besides play a domiciled here, but SUVs' gangly beforehand fascias are besides importantly much vulnerable for cyclists and pedestrians during nan crash. In an impact, nan fascia strikes nan pedestrians and cyclists straight successful nan caput and chest, which are nan astir susceptible parts of nan body. Meanwhile, sedans are engineered to onslaught a pedestrian astatine nan legs, pinch nan caput and thorax hitting nan hood pinch little sizeable force. Let's not forget: Heavier vehicles deed harder.

SUVs besides negatively impact wide municipality visibility – and not conscionable for nan driver. Pedestrians and cyclists besides acquisition restricted sightlines astatine intersections erstwhile SUVs are involved. Some are truthful precocious and wide that peeking complete aliases astir them is intolerable for astir people. Meanwhile, nan little floor plan of a sedan preserves a clear statement of show for pedestrians and cyclists, letting them spot complete nan conveyance and expect distant traffic. For cyclists and pedestrians, early discovery is cardinal to avoiding accidents.

SUVs are safer successful multi-vehicle crashes — nary mobility astir that. However, heavy, high-riding vehicles increase nan consequence of fatality for occupants successful smaller, lower-riding vehicles during collisions. This happens because nan rotation cages of these vehicles are historically misaligned, pinch SUVs usually overriding nan sedan's crumple zones. In different words, alternatively of hitting nan sedan's beforehand extremity directly, SUVs tin spell complete it and bypass the structures designed to sorb impacts. The aforesaid goes for T-bone broadside crashes, arsenic immoderate SUVs are truthful precocious that they tin deed nan doorway panels aliases model glass. A investigation by nan National Bureau of Economic Research indicates that being struck by a conveyance weighing an further 1,000 pounds raises nan baseline fatality consequence by 47%.

Regulators and automakers person worked connected this rumor and introduced bumper-matching standards. As a result, importantly less deaths now hap for passengers successful lower-riding vehicles erstwhile an SUV is involved. Passengers successful sedans are still astatine a somewhat higher consequence (although it's importantly little coming than successful nan past) chiefly owed to nan excess weight of SUVs. This is particularly nan lawsuit for SUVs heavier than 5,000 pounds (such as the Chevrolet Tahoe/Suburban), which are 20% much apt to consequence successful car-partner fatalities.