Why Most Electric Cars Don't Need A Traditional Transmission

Even though North America is being left down erstwhile it comes to EV sales, there's nary uncertainty customer tastes person begun to displacement connected a world basis. But what's not being shifted are nan vehicles themselves. With a fewer uncommon exceptions, EVs don't person multi-speed gearboxes, and that's because they conscionable don't request them. To understand why, however, let's first look astatine what accepted transmissions do successful cars pinch soul combustion engines.

It each starts pinch really accelerated those engines tin rotation and erstwhile those rpm nutrient highest torque. Basically — very fundamentally — state engines person little rpm limits and narrower torque bands than electrical motors and person to usage gears to dress up for it. The little rpm limits are a facet of physics, since nan engine's portion tin only move truthful accelerated earlier causing deterioration and damage, and nan engine's valves can't decently set nan fuel-air substance erstwhile they transcend a definite speed. That besides affects motor torque, because if an motor is spinning excessively slowly, it won't beryllium capable to tie successful capable fuel/air to make capable amounts of power.

By their nature, electrical motors tin present afloat torque almost immediately, positive they tin rotation astatine up to 30,000 rpm. Let's do immoderate mini magnitude of mathematics to show really each this works.

Jens Mommens/Shutterstock

We're going to return our lead — and our numbers — from Engineering Explained. First, support successful mind that it's not that EVs person nary gears, it's that their transmissions usage a azygous gear. The car from Engineering Explained, for instance, is from Formula E, location of immoderate of the champion racing connected nan planet, and has a cogwheel ratio of 11.4:1. This intends nan centrifugal has to rotation 11.4 times for nan wheels to move once. With nan centrifugal having a redline of 20,000 rpm, and taking into relationship nan tyre circumference, nan consequence is simply a apical velocity of astir 225 kph (140 mph).

If a state motor has nan aforesaid cogwheel ratio 11.4:1, its little redline — say, 6,000 rpm — would only beryllium bully for a velocity of 67.5 kph (42 mph). If you wanted to spell 140 mph, and who wouldn't, nan cogwheel ratio would person to beryllium 3.4:1 utilizing nan aforesaid formula. Yet if you wanted to putter astir nan vicinity successful your state car astatine 20 kph (12 mph), nan aforesaid ratio would mean your motor would beryllium sputtering astatine a specified 530 rpm — not accelerated capable for normal operation. So that's 2 different gears for 2 ends of nan velocity spectrum, and much are utilized for optimum driving astatine different velocities. The electrical motor, remember, makes highest torque moreover while moving astatine debased rpm, and pinch nary worries astir aerial aliases fuel, allowing you to usage nan aforesaid ratio astatine immoderate speed.

Of course, that doesn't mean EV motors can't beryllium utilized pinch multi-speed transmissions. The original Tesla Roadster had a two-speed transmission erstwhile it debuted successful 2008, and today, nan Porsche Taycan Turbo trims — which, to beryllium clear, are EVs without turbochargers — and nan Audi e-tron GT, which rides connected nan aforesaid platform, person two-speed setups.

In nan Taycan, nan first has a ratio of astir 15:1 and is meant for maximum acceleration. It much than delivers, too, arsenic nan Turbo S takes a specified 2.8 seconds to move from 0 to 62 mph. The 2nd cogwheel ratio of astir 8:1 is for enhanced ratio and is really utilized for astir driving. You person to put nan Porsche into Sport aliases Sport Plus modes to bask first gear.

And for next-level thrills, track-day fans will emotion nan Taycan Turbo GT that upgrades capacity to little its 0-60 clip to 2.1 seconds (with nan disposable Weissach Pack). The Audi variants aren't rather arsenic quick, pinch nan RS e-tron mounting nan gait pinch a people of 2.4 seconds successful nan 0-60 sprint. True, that's a reasonably pricey brace of cars, but group pinch much normal budgets tin return heart. Toyota and Ford some person patents for EV transmissions that tin make it consciousness arsenic if you're shifting for yourself.