Why Has The Man City 115 Charges Case Taken So Long?

Manchester City and nan Premier League are awaiting nan verdict aft a proceeding into nan 115 charges nan nine person faced since February 2023.

The charges subordinate to a number of alleged norm breaches by City betwixt 2009 and 2018.

The number of charges and severity of nan accusations are among nan reasons nan lawsuit has taken arsenic agelong arsenic it has.

"The connection 'unprecedented' is often utilized much than it should beryllium successful nan footballing world, but successful this lawsuit it really is justified," said lawyer Simon Leaf - caput of athletics astatine Mishcon de Reya.

City's proceeding started successful September 2024 and lasted 10 weeks. In February 2025, head Pep Guardiola said nan nine expected to study nan verdict "within 1 month".

Six months on, nan result is yet to beryllium made public.

"We person ne'er seen thing for illustration this type of lawsuit successful nan history of English shot and arguably successful world football," added Leaf.

"Given nan standard of nan allegations, nan quality of nan charges and nan attack to handling nan matter that each broadside has taken, astir experts are not amazed that we are still waiting for a decision."

The 115 charges person been surgery down to 5 different categories.

• 54x Failure to supply meticulous financial accusation 2009-10 to 2017-18.

• 14x Failure to supply meticulous specifications for subordinate and head payments from 2009-10 to 2017-18.

• 5x Failure to comply pinch Uefa's rules including Financial Fair Play (FFP) 2013-14 to 2017-18.

• 7x Breaching Premier League's PSR rules 2015-16 to 2017-18.

• 35x Failure to co-operate pinch Premier League investigations December 2018 - Feb 2023.

The lengths City went to successful their defence look to person prolonged matters.

"The ineligible teams involved... I'm beautiful judge nan Premier League has ne'er travel up against thing for illustration this," said Yasin Patel - barrister astatine Church Court Chambers.

"The squad of lawyers Manchester City person assembled... telephone it a ace squad if you want.

"There's a batch riding connected it for nan Premier League arsenic good arsenic Manchester City."

There person been suggestions by nan Times and shot finance master Kieran Maguire nan number of charges is arsenic precocious arsenic 130.

"I deliberation nan Premier League will person been taken aback, arsenic good arsenic nan arbitration sheet really, really Manchester City person travel pinch their defence," added Patel.

"They've been defending from correct up front, attacking nan Premier League successful position of their defence and making judge they've been fierce successful position of what they've said nan Premier League is incorrect on."

A batch of shot fans person drawn comparisons to nan cases brought by nan Premier League against Nottingham Forest and Everton respectively complete breaches to Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR).

During nan 2023-24 season, some clubs were docked points for making much losses than they were permitted to for nan three-year play from nan 2020-21 to 2022-23 seasons.

Those cases were of a azygous charge, were easier to decipher and progressive importantly little evidence.

"The Forest and Everton cases were, to a definite extent, very clear-cut. They were an open-and-shut case," said Maguire.

"There was 50,000 pieces of grounds put guardant by some parties.

"In nan lawsuit of Manchester City, you're going to person to multiply that by astir apt a facet of 10, truthful we could beryllium looking astatine half a cardinal pieces of evidence, which person to beryllium reflected upon by nan 3 group successful nan commission.

"They're besides successful request successful their ain jobs truthful trying to get them astir a array connected a regular ground isn't needfully easy and that's why 8 months later we're still not really further down nan roadworthy successful position of a conclusion to nan grounds referral and past making a verdict."

Earlier this month, Tottenham president Daniel Levy said nan process had "gone connected for acold excessively long".

In response, Premier League CEO Richard Masters told BBC Sport: "The only constituent wherever I tin speak publically astir it is erstwhile a determination has been handed down.

"I can't estimate astir why aliases when, that's each I tin opportunity really. Daniel is not successful nan aforesaid position arsenic maine and I can't talk astir it."

He added: "There is nary happy replacement to enforcing nan rules. It goes towards nan integrity of nan title and I don't deliberation that rule should beryllium frayed because it is excessively difficult, excessively complex, excessively costly."

While location is vexation among galore shot supporters that a verdict has not been made public, those progressive will cognize nan value of getting it right.

"The latest rumours, and they are thing but rumours, is we could beryllium waiting until astir about October earlier a verdict," said Maguire.

"There has been a complete lockdown. There are nary leaks. I deliberation this is suggestive of nan level of professionalism of nan group who are connected nan commission."

Patel was clear a verdict would not beryllium rushed.

He said: "I suppose nan nationalist connection from nan sheet will be: 'We are trying to get this determination arsenic quickly arsenic imaginable truthful we tin get this complete and done with.'

"None of nan fans are going to judge that.

"No matter really overmuch nan fans jump up and down each astir nan country, I'm acrophobic nary sheet is going to beryllium rushed."

Patel besides thinks nan longer nan wait, nan "better it is for Manchester City".

"We each cognize what immoderate of nan imaginable penalties are, successful peculiar points deductions, and I would person thought they would person fixed them by now," he added.

"The truth they haven't mightiness propose it's not arsenic bad for Man City arsenic group are predicting."

Whoever comes retired connected apical - beryllium it nan Premier League aliases Manchester City - it is almost definite nan verdict will not bring nan saga to an end.

If nan Premier League wins, clubs who person possibly mislaid titles aliases successful cup competitions to City during nan play covered by nan charges whitethorn declare for nonaccomplishment of earnings, beryllium it done prize money aliases competitions they grounded to suffice for.

If City win, they could declare for damages caused arsenic a consequence of nan case.

"Whatever comes retired of it, I'm acrophobic that's not nan extremity of nan title title for some parties here," said Patel. "This is simply a two-horse title that's going to transportation on."

"Whatever verdict comes out, I wouldn't deliberation that's nan extremity of it. I would appeal, whether I was connected 1 broadside aliases nan other."

This article is nan latest from BBC Sport's Ask Me Anything team.

Ask Me Anything is simply a work dedicated to answering your questions.

We want to reward your clip by telling you things you do not cognize and reminding you of things you do.

The squad will find retired everything you request to cognize and beryllium capable to telephone upon a web of contacts including our experts and pundits.

We will beryllium answering your questions from nan bosom of nan BBC Sport newsroom, and going down nan scenes astatine immoderate of nan world's biggest sporting events.

Our sum will span nan BBC Sport website, app, societal media and YouTube accounts, positive BBC TV and radio.