What The Hell Is Going On With Subnautica 2?

If I had to picture nan position of Subnautica 2 successful conscionable 3 words, it would beryllium these: messy, messy, messy. That’s not to opportunity nan crippled itself is successful unspeakable style — this is really a pivotal declare successful nan full business — but nan narration betwixt Subnautica bid developer Unknown Worlds and its genitor company, Krafton, is successful shreds. This period alone, Krafton fired nan founders and CEO of Unknown Worlds, Subnautica 2 was delayed until 2026 and nan ousted leaders revenge a suit against Krafton, looking to regain imaginative power of nan crippled and nan studio. At nan halfway of nan conflict is simply a prize costs worthy up to $250 million.

Here’s a rundown of really we sewage present and what successful nan devil is going connected pinch Subnautica 2, Krafton and Unknown Worlds.

Charlie Cleveland accidentally started Unknown Worlds successful 2001 while building nan celebrated Half-Life mods Natural Selection and Natural Selection 2, and method head Max McGuire came connected arsenic an charismatic workplace co-founder successful 2006. Inspired by Minecraft and burned retired connected mods, Unknown Worlds began moving connected nan undersea, open-world exploration crippled Subnautica and released it successful early entree connected Steam successful 2014. With years of organization feedback, nan crippled evolved into a singularly tense and rich | endurance experience, and type 1.0 officially landed successful 2018. This is besides erstwhile Ted Gill joined nan studio’s executive team, freeing up Cleveland to attraction connected imaginative direction. Subnautica and its spin-off, Subnautica: Below Zero, attracted millions of players and established Unknown Worlds arsenic a successful independent team.

So, nan larger studios came sniffing. PUBG patient Krafton, which operates pinch billions of dollars annually, purchased Unknown Worlds successful 2021 for $500 million. The acquisition came pinch nan committedness of an further payout worthy up to $250 cardinal if Unknown Worlds deed definite capacity goals by nan extremity of 2025. This prize is simply a captious portion of nan chaos today.

We cognize much astir nan specifications of this woody acknowledgment to caller reporting by Bloomberg. In summation to nan activity positions, which were filled by Cleveland, Gill and McGuire, Unknown Worlds had astir 40 labor astatine nan clip of nan Krafton sale, and they received payouts totaling $50 cardinal astatine closing and complete nan pursuing 2 years. This larger group was poised to person arsenic overmuch arsenic $25 cardinal successful nan 2025 performance-based earnout, pinch each personification expecting a different amount, but astir estimating six aliases 7 figures. The remaining $225 cardinal was reserved for nan Unknown Worlds leadership, but they said they intended to stock a information of their windfall pinch labor who weren’t included successful nan bonus, covering nan afloat workplace headcount of astir 100 people.

The activity of Unknown Worlds repeated this committedness successful a suit revenge against Krafton connected July 10, 2025. But we’re getting up of ourselves.

After nan acquisition, Unknown Worlds continued updating Subnautica and Below Zero. In February 2024, nan workplace released Moonbreaker, a turn-based strategy crippled that ne'er really took off, partially because of its initial microtransaction system. Since then, nan workplace has been focused connected Subnautica 2. The crippled was officially announced successful October 2024 pinch a prospective early entree motorboat model of 2025. It’s presently nan second-most wishlisted crippled connected Steam, aft Hollow Knight: Silksong.

The first nationalist conception that thing was rotten betwixt Unknown Worlds and Krafton came connected July 2, erstwhile Cleveland, Gill and McGuire were fired and replaced by erstwhile Callisto Protocol workplace caput Steve Papoutsis. Krafton didn’t supply a logic for nan switch-up in its property release, alternatively offering nan pursuing astir complete thought: “While Krafton sought to support nan Unknown Worlds’ co-founders and original creators of nan Subnautica bid progressive successful nan game’s development, nan institution wishes them good connected their adjacent endeavors.”

Krafton didn’t mention delaying nan early entree motorboat astatine this time, but it implemented a reappraisal process that it said would beryllium “essential to delivering nan correct crippled astatine nan correct time.” The patient suggested nan ousted leaders had been uncooperative successful this aspect.

“Unknown Worlds’ caller activity afloat supports this process and is committed to gathering subordinate expectations,” its property merchandise said.

Cleveland published a blog post connected July 4 reflecting connected his clip successful crippled development, and sharing his disappointment astatine Krafton’s handling of Unknown Worlds and Subnautica 2. He besides referenced Krafton’s intent to hold nan launch.

“You tin spot why for Max, Ted, myself, nan Unknown Worlds team, and for our community, nan events of this week person been rather a shock,” Cleveland wrote. “We cognize that nan crippled is fresh for early entree merchandise and we cognize you’re fresh to play it. And while we thought this was going to beryllium our determination to make, astatine slightest for now, that determination is successful Krafton’s hands. And aft each these years, to find that I’m nary longer capable to activity astatine nan institution I started stings.”

On July 9, Krafton officially delayed nan early entree launch of Subnautica 2 to 2026. That aforesaid day, Bloomberg published a study outlining nan performance-based prize statement and implicitly questioning really nan timing of nan hold would make it difficult for nan workplace to deed its goals, putting nan payout successful jeopardy. This was nan first clip nan specifications of nan prize became public.

Krafton shared a statement pinch Engadget — and successful a pop-up connected its ain homepage — connected July 10 that straight-up accused nan fired leaders of abandoning nan workplace successful favour of individual imaginative pursuits, specifically calling retired Cleveland’s film accumulation company. It besides threw shadiness astatine Moonbreaker and claimed nan erstwhile bosses wanted nan prize costs “for themselves.”

“Krafton made aggregate requests to Charlie and Max to resume their roles arsenic Game Director and Technical Director, respectively, but some declined to do so,” nan connection said. “In particular, pursuing nan nonaccomplishment of Moonbreaker, Krafton asked Charlie to give himself to nan improvement of Subnautica 2. However, alternatively of participating successful nan crippled development, he chose to attraction connected a individual movie project. Krafton believes that nan absence of halfway activity has resulted successful repeated disorder successful guidance and important delays successful nan wide task schedule. The existent Early Access type besides falls short successful position of contented volume.”

That aforesaid day, Cleveland announced that he and nan different ousted workplace heads had filed a lawsuit against Krafton.

“Suing a multibillion dollar institution successful a painful, nationalist and perchance prolonged measurement was surely not connected my bucket list,” Cleveland wrote. “But this needs to beryllium made right. Subnautica has been my life’s activity and I would ne'er willingly wantonness it aliases nan astonishing squad that has poured their hearts into it. As for nan earnout, nan thought that Max, Ted and I wanted to support it each for ourselves is wholly untrue.”

The suit wasn’t unsealed until July 16. But connected July 15, Bloomberg reported that Krafton now planned to widen nan model for nan prize costs by an further year, giving nan workplace much clip to deed its goals. The patient will besides reportedly beforehand a information of a abstracted profit-sharing prize excavation to each Unknown Worlds labor successful 2025.

These moves look designed to moot nan halfway issues raised successful nan breach of statement title that Cleveland and different Unknown Worlds leaders revenge against Krafton successful Delaware Chancery Court. The lawsuit, unsealed connected July 16, claims Krafton illegally fired nan workplace heads and delayed Subnautica 2 successful bid to debar nan prize payments. It besides provides a timeline of increasing tensions betwixt nan founders and Krafton this year, accusing nan patient of intentional sabotage.

The suit claims that Krafton and Unknown Worlds had a respectful narration until April 2025, erstwhile Gill presented Krafton executives pinch nan studio’s affirmative gross projections, which were made pinch nan presumption that Subnautica 2 would deed early entree successful 2025. He besides outlined nan expected prize payout nether nan agreement.

“When that happened, everything changed,” nan suit reads.

The title alleges that astatine this point, Krafton began looking for ways to unit retired nan leaders of Unknown Worlds and hold nan motorboat of Subnautica 2, pinch a extremity of circumventing nan prize payment. Cleveland, Gill and McGuire based on backmost and distant pinch Krafton executives complete whether nan crippled was fresh for early access, and Krafton yet pulled each of its resources from nan studio. Krafton issued a extremity bid connected Subnautica 2 development, took complete Unknown Worlds’ communications channels and successful June it started laying an soul insubstantial way accusing nan founders of abandoning their fiduciary duties, according to nan complaint.

Cleveland, Gill and McGuire were fired and removed from nan Unknown Worlds committee of board connected July 1. This is wherever nan remainder of america entered nan story.

The main conflict present is complete whether Subnautica 2 is really fresh for an early entree launch, and that matters because of a imaginable $250 cardinal prize costs that’s jeopardized by a delay. Not only is this a ample sum for Krafton to lose, but it’s besides a monolithic magnitude of money for Cleveland, Gill and McGuire to miss retired on, particularly now that they’ve mislaid their workplace and tentpole IP. The ousted leaders reiterated successful their suit that they “planned to stock moreover much of nan earnout pinch their dedicated team” than they were contractually obligated to. In nan complaint, they’re looking for Krafton to salary retired nan afloat prize arsenic projected without a delay, fulfill its obligations arsenic a patient and reinstate them arsenic nan heads of Unknown Worlds.

Every statement successful this business claims they want what’s champion for Subnautica 2 and its players. It’s imaginable that they’re each telling nan truth and this is simply a elemental disagreement complete creator integrity. It’s besides imaginable that they’re each lying and everyone is looking to make (or keep) a speedy subordinate — but man, that’s bleak. The truth, arsenic usual, apt lies location successful betwixt and, chances are, we’ll ne'er cognize it. At slightest nan tribunal strategy will yet beryllium capable to find nan second-best thing, which is who’s astatine fault.

Have a extremity for Jessica? You tin scope her by email, Bluesky aliases nonstop a connection to @jesscon.96 to chat confidentially connected Signal.

If you bargain thing done a nexus successful this article, we whitethorn gain commission.