U.s. Envoy Witkoff's Visit To Gaza Criticized As A Publicity Stunt

1 month ago

Weeks of rising anger complete Palestinians starving owed to Israel's violative and assistance restrictions had reached each nan measurement to nan White House, pinch President Donald Trump lamenting nan show of emaciated children connected nan brink of starvation.

On Friday, his Middle East envoy, Steve Witkoff, entered Gaza successful a uncommon sojourn by high-level U.S. officials to nan besieged enclave.

Accompanied by nan Israeli military, Witkoff visited an assistance distribution tract successful confederate Gaza tally by nan U.S. and Israeli-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, wherever hundreds of Palestinians waited desperately down barbed ligament for food.

“Incredible feat!” Mike Huckabee, nan U.S. ambassador to Israel, who accompanied Witkoff, said successful a station connected X connected Friday, aft touring GHF's operations and speaking to "folks connected nan ground."

Palestinians and others wrong Gaza person criticized nan sojourn arsenic a nationalist relations stunt for GHF, whose assistance distribution process has been marked by chaos, looting and deadly shootings, often by Israeli soldiers, that person killed hundreds of quiet Palestinians seeking aid.

“It was a PR stunt, a controlled sojourn supervised and dictated by nan Israeli military,” Ellie Burgos, an American captious attraction caregiver volunteering astatine Nasser Hospital successful Khan Younis, told nan NBC News crew. “What they saw was not nan reality.”

Burgos had earlier called for Witkoff to sojourn Gaza, urging him to witnesser nan conditions connected nan ground for himself, but felt his constricted circuit did small to alteration nan business connected nan ground.

“Food is still incredibly difficult to find, group are still being changeable astatine assistance distribution sites, and unit continues,” she said.

On nan time of nan visit, astatine slightest 92 group were killed connected Friday crossed Gaza, including 51 group who were seeking aid, Dr. Mohammed Saqr, Director of Nursing astatine Nasser Hospital, told NBC News.

Mohamed Saddak, 47, who was hoping to cod nutrient for his family of nine, told a NBC News' unit connected nan crushed that tanks had precocious toward him and others arsenic they sought to person our aid.

“They are perpetually shooting astatine us,” he said, “firing from tanks, and sometimes by drones.”

TOPSHOT-ISRAEL-PALESTINIAN-CONFLICT-HOTAGES

The IDF did not instantly respond to a petition for remark from NBC News connected nan shootings astatine assistance sites pursuing Witkoff's visit.

Israeli officials continued to contradict claims of wide hunger wrong Gaza, though successful a motion of shifting discourse, apical U.S. officials person begun to admit nan crisis.

“You’ve sewage small kids who are intelligibly starving to death,” Vice President JD Vance told reporters connected Monday.

In a post connected X, Witkoff said nan visit's intent was to springiness Trump a "clear knowing of nan humanitarian business and thief trade a scheme to present nutrient and aesculapian assistance to nan group of Gaza."

After Gaza, Witkoff connected Saturday visited Hostages Square successful Tel Aviv, wherever families of Israeli hostages held captive by Hamas were demanding that nan Israeli authorities unafraid a woody to merchandise nan remaining hostages. Fifty hostages stay successful Gaza, astir 20 of whom are believed to beryllium alive.

According to a connection by nan Hostages and Missing Families Forum, Witkoff told them, “We will get your children location and clasp Hamas responsible for immoderate bad acts connected their part.” He added, “We will do what’s correct for nan Gazan people.”

The protests came aft a video of an Israeli hostage successful Gaza, Rom Braslavski, was released by nan Palestinian Islamic Jihad connected Thursday. A time later, Hamas released a video of different Israeli hostage, Evyatar David, showing him live but frail. It is unclear erstwhile nan videos were filmed.

“We cannot strengthen moreover 1 much infinitesimal without bringing him home,” Braslavski’s relative Adam Hajaj said successful a statement. “This video tore my family apart!”

Huckabee, meanwhile, hailed GHF's distribution of complete a cardinal meals a day, which astatine Gaza's organization of astir 2 cardinal people, averages to half a repast per personification per day.

GHF stepped successful to administer nutrient successful nan weeks aft Israel lifted its astir three-month total blockade connected each nutrient and supplies entering nan enclave. But nan assistance GHF distributed, alongside immoderate constricted quantities by different world organizations, fell acold short of nan needs of nan population. On Sunday, Israel said it was expanding assistance entree into Gaza aft outrage mounted complete nan wide starvation and surging deaths from malnutrition.

GHF runs 4 assistance sites successful Gaza and moreover though it claims independency from immoderate government, it runs nan sites wrong Israel's militarized area pinch nan backing of nan Israeli military.

Witnesses and assistance agencies person decried nan assistance transportation process, which, according to nan U.N., has resulted successful deaths of astir 1,400 group while collecting aid, including 859 successful nan vicinity of nan GHF sites.

The Israeli subject and nan GHF person acknowledged that immoderate shots person been fired but said only arsenic warnings.

“US-backed Israeli forces and backstage contractors person put successful spot a flawed, militarized assistance distribution strategy that has turned assistance distributions into regular bloodbaths,” New York-based Human Rights Watch said Friday.

Burgos's colleague, Dr. Tom Adamekiewicz, urged nan diplomats to spot "what’s happening to nan children, nan families, to these young boys and women and men that are being fundamentally changeable astatine for illustration rabbits."