North Carolina Lawmakers Take Aim At Hospitals’ Prized Tax Perks

By Michelle Crouch

As North Carolina lawmakers hunt for ways to trim nan taxation load for authorities residents, they’re taking purpose astatine nan generous taxation breaks nan state’s nonprofit and nationalist hospitals person agelong enjoyed.

Proposals discussed by a House committee connected March 18 would importantly standard backmost 2 cardinal taxation exemptions. If passed, they would people 1 of nan astir important efforts successful years to trim infirmary taxation breaks and could nonstop millions to nan authorities and section governments.

Under existent law, nonprofit and authorities hospitals are exempt from spot taxes and tin person up to $45 cardinal a twelvemonth successful income taxation refunds. The projected authorities would trim nan spot taxation break successful half, meaning only 50 percent of a hospital’s spot would stay tax-exempt. A abstracted measure would little nan income taxation refund headdress from $45 cardinal to $14.2 million.

The Ledger/NC Health News has spotlighted some types of taxation breaks:

• Our study of spot taxation exemptions successful 2023 recovered that hospitals ain exempt spot weighted astatine $6.3 cardinal successful North Carolina’s 5 astir populous counties, based connected 2022 assessed values. That includes much than $2.4 cardinal owned by Atrium Health and Novant Health successful Mecklenburg County unsocial — which would bring successful astatine slightest $23 cardinal a twelvemonth to section governments if nan onshore were not exempt from spot taxes.

• A 2025 investigation revealed that Atrium Health sidesteps nan state’s $45 cardinal headdress connected income taxation refunds by filing refund requests arsenic 2 abstracted entities: Atrium Health Wake Forest Baptist and a authorities entity that does business arsenic Atrium Health. (Atrium stressed that its filings were ineligible and that it invests billions successful nan community.)  

Rep. Julie Howard, R-Davie, who co-chairs nan House Select Committee connected Property Tax Reduction and Reform, cited nan Ledger/NC Health News’s reporting connected Atrium astatine a February committee gathering erstwhile discussing nan request for income taxation reform.

At nan March 18 meeting, she said that moreover though nan believe of filing for income taxation refunds nether 2 abstracted entities is legal, it’s “a loophole that is costing taxpayers money.”

“It was not nan intent,” she said, adding that Atrium has “real bully ineligible counsel.  That was not nan measurement it was expected to be.”

The projected authorities would adjacent nan loophole by requiring each nan connection organizations of a nonprofit aliases nationalist infirmary to beryllium treated arsenic 1 entity erstwhile applying nan refund cap.

Hospitals raise concerns astir impact

Stephanie Strickland, a spokeswoman for nan North Carolina Healthcare Association, which represents hospitals, said past week that nan group is reviewing nan measure proposals and looks guardant to “continued dialogue” pinch nan committee and nan General Assembly to guarantee that hospitals tin proceed gathering patients’ needs.

“Many hospitals successful North Carolina, peculiarly those serving agrarian and underserved communities, run connected very mini margins,” she said successful an email. “Proposals that further strain infirmary resources raise superior concerns astir nan imaginable effect connected patients, entree to attraction and hospitals’ expertise to reinvest successful captious services, some wrong their accommodation and successful nan communities they serve.”

Asked separately for remark past week, Atrium Health emailed a short consequence that it doesn’t “speculate connected projected aliases draught legislation.” 

The House committee was formed to analyse ways to easiness rising spot taxes, which lawmakers opportunity are forcing immoderate residents retired of their homes, peculiarly seniors connected a fixed income and group pinch disabilities. Members besides discussed a draught law amendment that would limit really overmuch section governments tin summation spot taxes each year. 

The committee is expected to ballot successful April connected which bills to nonstop to nan afloat authorities House of Representatives; immoderate authorities would besides request Senate approval. 

The effort to restrict infirmary taxation breaks comes arsenic aesculapian costs support soaring for patients and galore hospitals person grown into large businesses that study double-digit net maturation and pay their apical executives millions. 

Atrium, nan state’s largest infirmary system, is portion of Advocate Health, a $32 cardinal institution pinch 162,000 labor successful six states. 

Hospitals person agelong been nan biggest beneficiaries of nan state’s income taxation refunds, collecting astir $280 cardinal — aliases 71 percent — of nan astir $400 cardinal of income taxation refunded each year, according to a legislative report.

When lawmakers created nan income taxation refund headdress successful 2013, they were trying to rein successful ample nonprofits they said were flush pinch rate but still collecting generous taxation refunds, nan Ledger/NC Health News reported. But aft dense lobbying from nan hospitals, nan $45 cardinal limit was group truthful precocious that it was mostly considered symbolic. Nonetheless, immoderate infirmary systems are now hitting it.

At nan aforesaid time, section governments are missing retired connected accrued spot taxation gross arsenic hospitals aggressively expand by buying doctor’s offices, imaging centers and clinics which, arsenic a result, are removed from nan taxation rolls.

The worth of nonprofit infirmary spot crossed nan authorities has jumped astir 40 percent successful 4 years, according to nan legislative report. Analysts said that translates to astir $130 cardinal a twelvemonth that cities and counties could beryllium collecting, but aren’t.

What infirmary spot should beryllium exempt?

As hospitals grow and return much spot disconnected nan taxation rolls, lawmakers are besides questioning what types of hospital-owned spot should suffice for a taxation exemption.

Legislative analysts told nan committee successful February that immoderate states exclude definite types of infirmary spot specified arsenic aesculapian agency buildings, unit abstraction connected infirmary grounds, administrative buildings and recreational facilities.

A 2023 Ledger/NC Health News article highlighted a PDQ chickenhearted edifice connected Atrium Health spot successful Cornelius that was exempt from spot taxes — and still is, according to Mecklenburg County taxation records accessed and examined past week. (Atrium stressed successful 2023 that it voluntarily pays spot taxes connected different parcels that it could declare exemptions on.)

Renewed liking successful a installation interest ban

Separately, a different legislative committee connected precocious revisited infirmary installation fees — charges meant to screen infirmary overhead that are progressively added to aesculapian bills, moreover for attraction miles distant from a hospital. 

A Senate measure to prohibition nan fees successful nonhospital settings stalled successful a House committee past year.

The Joint Legislative Oversight Committee connected Health and Human Services heard arguments from supporters and critics of nan fees connected March 10. One presentation cited a Charlotte Ledger story astir a diligent who was deed pinch a $5,300 installation interest for a colonoscopy. It besides highlighted a Ledger/NC Health News article that told nan communicative of a diligent who was charged $200 much per sojourn aft UNC Health started coding his visits to a doctor’s agency arsenic “hospital outpatient” care.

Want to measurement in? You tin email your feedback to nan members of nan committee reviewing nan authorities utilizing their publicly disposable interaction information.

This article is portion of a business betwixt The Charlotte Ledger and North Carolina Health News to produce original wellness attraction reporting. You tin support this effort with a tax-deductible donation.

Republish our articles for free, online aliases successful print, nether a Creative Commons license.