James Tarkowski, Confused Pundits And A Mess That’s Hard To Handle

3 weeks ago

TARK ARTS?

We tin only estimate astir what David Moyes would person said successful his post-match property convention if it had been his squad who had been awarded a punishment successful identical circumstances to those starring to Leeds United scoring their victor against Everton past night, but location really isn’t overmuch point. Like beautiful overmuch each shot manager, Everton’s tends to beryllium beautiful accordant successful his position that debatable decisions that spell successful favour of his players are correct and to beryllium commended, while those which spell against them are not and should beryllium criticised. Twas ever thus, truthful it was nary astonishment that erstwhile James Tarkowski was penalised for deliberately leaning to his near to extremity a shot that would different person not struck his limb astatine a febrile Elland Road, Moyes decided his subordinate and squad had been highly difficult done by, moreover if did look reasonably relaxed and wasn’t successful full-on Begbie radge-funk mode.

Moyes was acold from unsocial successful this view, moreover if those espoused by erstwhile players – nan group that immoderate geniuses would person infiltrate Stockley Park’s bunker of squinting windows because they’ve played nan game – were wildly divergent. BBC pundit Chris Sutton declared nan determination “scandalous”, while his Sky Sports counterparts Gary Neville and Jamie Carragher agreed referee Chris Kavanagh had sewage it right. “I’m evidently going to opportunity it’s not a punishment and I judge it’s not a penalty,” growled Moyes aft nan game. “I’ve been to spot nan referee. [Kavanagh] benignant of took thing to do pinch it, he thought it was to do pinch VAR, nan determination they’ve made. I don’t cognize what other I tin say.” He went connected to opportunity plentifulness arsenic he criticised nan modular of refereeing crossed nan committee complete nan play conscionable gone, moreover though it seemed mostly good to Football Daily isolated from 1 aliases 2 insignificant ricks from officialdom.

While nan misguided guidance of various members of nan punditocracy to nan wholly correct determination to disallow Eberechi Eze’s free-kick for Crystal Palace against Chelsea connected Sunday demonstrated that nary extremity of erstwhile footballers unrecorded successful blissful ignorance of nan laws of nan crippled they are now tasked pinch discussing for a living, handball is an wholly different kettle of oversea bream. Since nan preamble of VAR, changeless tinkering has rendered nan rule truthful diluted, murky and subjective that nan fabled “consistency” players, managers and fans everyplace request has go intolerable to achieve.

Indeed, it is nary exaggeration to opportunity that nan handball rule has go truthful opaque and unfastened to interpretation, 1 suspects a bully lawyer could reason convincingly that each and each 1 of Moyes, his other number Daniel Farke, Sutton, Carragher, Neville and each nan net crazies who debated agelong into nan nighttime were spot-on successful their assessments of really it was applied against Tarkowski and Everton. A messiness that shows nary motion of being tidied up anytime soon, handball will proceed to beryllium a talking constituent pinch each passing match. Such was nan paucity of value astatine Elland Road, it was successful truth nan only talking constituent from that peculiar game.

QUOTE OF THE DAY

“This accomplishment isn’t conscionable ours – it belongs to each woman successful Bangladesh who dares to dream. It’s impervious of what faith, difficult work, and unity tin achieve. But we’re not stopping here. The adjacent fewer months of mentation will beryllium reliable but we are up for nan challenge” – Bangladesh’s 18-year-old captain, Afeida Khandaker, talks to Thaslima Begum about her side’s historical Asian Cup qualification successful nan latest version of our women’s shot newsletter, Moving nan Goalposts.

Afeida Khandaker, nan nationalist squad skipper of Bangladesh

Does Football Daily really want a chat connected caller words to beryllium included successful dictionaries [yesterday’s Last Line, afloat email edition]? For a time, I had projected that nan OED see nan connection ‘fiverish’. Common usages included ‘sort of funny, but not overly so’, and ‘tea-timely, but surely not connected time’. But past your large FD rebrand made nan word obsolete. Sigh” – Mike Wilner.

Do we request further explanation of nan handball rule to specifically norm connected nan business wherever it is arm-fastidiously-stuck-to-his-side-but-still-moved-towards-the-ball to ball?” – Darren Leathley.

If you person any, please nonstop letters to the.boss@theguardian.com. Today’s victor of our prizeless missive o’ nan time is … Mike Wilner. Terms and conditions for our competitions, erstwhile we tally them, tin beryllium viewed here.

RECOMMENDED LISTENING

The pod squad are backmost for another helping of Football Weekly, featuring Leeds’ winning Premier League return and nan latest from Europe’s mega-giants.

RECOMMENDED BOOKING

On Thursday 11 September, subordinate Max Rushden, Barry Glendenning and Football Weekly favourites Jonathan Wilson, Nicky Bandini and Jonathan Liew for an evening of unfiltered shot punditry astatine Troxy successful London. The pod will besides beryllium livestreamed globally. Book now.