I want to beryllium clear from nan outset. I’ve ne'er been a car enthusiast. My driving history includes a hand-me-down Volvo pinch a spread successful nan floorboards and a bid of aggressively applicable vehicles, including a VW Golf and a Mazda SUV successful which I hauled my family astir for 12 years. Then I leased a BMW i4 electrical car.
What drew maine to nan i4? Unlike different electrical vehicles, BMWs don’t look for illustration thing retired of nan Jetsons; I for illustration that they’re understated cars that hap to beryllium electric. I liked that they’re acold little communal than different EVs successful Northern California. Plus, nan i4 comes successful thing for illustration a twelve colors, including “Brooklyn Gray,” which – I cognize I sound ridiculous – delighted maine successful ways that Tesla’s fistful of options ne'er could. I’d publication online that early adopters were having package issues, but pinch visions of my sleek caller BMW dancing successful my head, I conveniently revenge that accusation away. Those first fewer drives felt exhilarating, too. The car was beautiful, nan thrust was smooth, and I felt for illustration we were going places.
Nearly 2 years later, I’m doing thing I ne'er thought I’d do: eagerly awaiting nan extremity of a lease connected a luxury car because its package is specified a disaster that it makes my rusted-out Volvo look for illustration a paragon of reliability.
A emotion communicative gone awry
Let maine count nan ways this narration has gone wrong, starting pinch nan astir basal function: getting into my ain car. On aggregate occasions, I’ve stood successful parking lots, incapable to unlock its doors pinch my telephone contempt nan BMW Digital Key being specifically designed for this purpose. This sounds trivial until you’re juggling pouring groceries while looking for illustration you’re trying to bargain your ain car.
Digital cardinal issues person go truthful wide that BMW owners person astatine times shared elaborate multi-step workarounds that publication for illustration instructions for disarming a bomb: “1. Open nan BMW app connected your telephone and usage it to unlock nan door. 2. Sign successful pinch your BMW ID successful iDrive. 3. Place your iPhone successful nan vehicle’s charging tray. 4. Wait for nan integer cardinal to reappear successful nan Wallet app. 5. Double-click nan broadside button, authenticate pinch Face ID, and—finally—start nan car.”
The personification floor plan strategy is different workout successful futility. I’ve been incapable to create impermanent profiles without being demoted to nan bottommost of nan personification hierarchy. What this intends successful believe is that if anyone other drives my car – moreover erstwhile – nan conveyance will drawback their telephone and playlist nan infinitesimal they’re wrong Bluetooth range. BMW has over-engineered their floor plan strategy to nan constituent wherever it requires definitive linking steps that should really hap automatically.
Techcrunch event
San Francisco | October 27-29, 2025
The car’s CarPlay integration ranges from mediocre to actively dangerous. Software updates routinely break CarPlay functionality, requiring complete reboots of its iDrive infotainment system. The reverse camera rumor is peculiarly maddening; put nan car successful reverse while utilizing CarPlay navigation, and erstwhile you displacement backmost to drive, you’re dumped onto nan location surface alternatively of returning to your directions.
The backup camera itself is practically useless successful debased ray conditions, and nan surface often becomes scorching basking to nan touch.
Then there’s nan lights issue. Unless I retrieve to manually fastener nan car aft stepping distant from it, I’ll occasionally announcement later that nan exterior lights are still ablaze successful my driveway. I thought it mightiness beryllium quality correction nan first clip it happened. By nan 3rd time, I realized that it’s a “feature” wherever nan i4 enters a “pseudo-sleep mode” that keeps lights and different systems moving indefinitely. Multiple owners study nan aforesaid issue: parkland nan car, locomotion away, return later to find their conveyance lit up for illustration a beacon and draining nan battery.
Beyond nan emotion connected a near-daily ground that nan car has amnesia, location are morganatic information concerns. The 2022 i4 was taxable to six recalls successful its first year, including 1 truthful superior that BMW told owners their cars were occurrence risks erstwhile parked and advised them to “stop driving this conveyance immediately.” Since then, other recalls person included artillery power units that tin origin a abrupt nonaccomplishment of power.
BMW releases package updates for nan i4 astir each fewer months, but nan process is fraught pinch issues. Updates routinely break connected services, causing owners to suffer entree to postulation information, upwind data, distant parking functions, and moreover nan MyBMW app connectivity.
The over-the-air update strategy itself is unreliable, pinch owners reporting updates that get stuck astatine various percentages for days, forcing trips to dealers for manual installation.
What’s particularly galling is that BMW positions these vehicles arsenic premium products. If you’re buying alternatively than leasing, nan i4 starts astatine complete $50,000, pinch well-equipped models pushing $70,000 aliases more. Meanwhile, owners of little costly vehicles, including Hyundais and Lexus models, study bulletproof connectivity and seamless personification experiences.
I’m not saying nan institution rushed these cars to marketplace without adequately testing their integer ecosystem, past decided to dainty their customers arsenic beta testers without taking their well-being into account, but I’m besides not not saying that.
I genuinely wanted this narration to work. The i4 is gorgeous, drives beautifully, and represents everything I thought I wanted successful an electrical vehicle. But I can’t proceed a narration wherever nan astir basal functions – unlocking doors, connecting my phone, getting directions – require nan patience of a saint. (I do not person nan patience of a saint.)
Even my tech-savvy husband, who is usually nan first to propose personification error, precocious emerged from nan car aft a peculiarly frustrating package meltdown and announced that he would “need to meditate for a bit.”
Car ownership shouldn’t beryllium a changeless root of aggravation. I shouldn’t person to support a intelligence database of workarounds for features that should conscionable work. I shouldn’t dread package updates because they mightiness break thing that was (mostly) functional.
So BMW, I’ve had it. You made a gorgeous car, past sabotaged it pinch package truthful crummy that it’s almost comical. I thought we’d thrust into nan sunset together. Instead, I’m driving my i4 backmost to nan dealership arsenic my lease is over. I’m amazed to opportunity I can’t wait.