Beyond Meat’s Ipo Success Story Withers Into Penny Stock Territory

Credit: BalkansCat / Shutterstock.com

All was rosy for Beyond Meat six years agone – alt-protein income were enjoying a roar and nan company’s shares rallied station its IPO to northbound of $230.

A calamity mightiness beryllium an understatement but TD Cowen analysts are predicting further declines arsenic nan US finance slope lowered its value target to 80 cents from $2.00. And 1 has to fishy that mightiness beryllium an underestimate unless Beyond Meat tin wring retired immoderate mammoth undertaking.

The problem is, efforts to do conscionable that person truthful acold grounded to present immoderate optimism, astatine best. After all, nan business has been loss-making ever since its marketplace debut successful May 2019. The pursuing year, Beyond Meat notched up a nonaccomplishment of $53m, which blew retired to $175m successful nan adjacent 12 months and $343m successful 2022.

Those were nan blossoming years for plant-based proteins, enabling Beyond Meat to grounds revenues supra $400m annually successful nan 3 years aft nan IPO. With that came world description – income successful caller markets specified arsenic Europe and China, and accumulation accommodation overseas.

However, nan past fewer years person been a different story. Most notably, alt-meat income person dwindled, not conscionable successful nan US but further afield. The much-publicised issues astir taste, texture, mouthfeel, and value person been nan main culprits, which defeated nan lofty aspirations of manufacture players and avid investors.

Back down to earth, Beyond Meat has suffered but is still conscionable surviving, while a big of different manufacturers person fallen by nan wayside. And nan flip to wellness successful nan aftermath of nan Covid pandemic hasn’t helped either, arsenic consumers scrutinise ingredients lists – different weight connected nan plant-based nutrient category.

All of these factors are now fusing together and Beyond Meat has dug heavy into its toolbox this twelvemonth to effort and find immoderate stableness but nan measures undertaken truthful acold person only served to exacerbate nan stock value declines.

Equity dilution

The latest, a indebtedness swap, replete pinch an action to switch indebtedness for equity. The completion of that programme was announced yesterday up of schedule. And nan shares tanked, taking losses this twelvemonth to 73%.

Key to nan shares’ demise was equity dilution. But astatine nan aforesaid time, Beyond Meat was swapping zero percent bonds pinch notes carrying an liking complaint of 7% arsenic it sought to trim indebtedness by astir $800m.

For a business that had $1.2bn of indebtedness successful June, arsenic per nan second-quarter results announcement successful August, 1 wonders if ramping up debt-servicing costs was a sensible people to take.

However, nan workout did widen nan maturity floor plan for Beyond Meat, which has been experiencing a cash-burn for immoderate time.

Investors had nan action of swapping existing zero percent convertible bonds owed successful 2027 into notes maturing successful 2030, on pinch an speech of up to circa 326 cardinal successful shares.

According to TD Cowen expert Robert Moskow, Beyond Meat exchanged its $1.11bn 0% convertible notes maturing successful 2027 for $196.2m of caller 7% convertible bonds owed successful 2030.

Moskow wrote successful a investigation statement that liking payments will summation nan complaint of cash-burn by $14m per year, while participating noteholders will person 316.2 cardinal successful caller shares.

As TD Cowen amended its value target for Beyond Meat, Moskow said nan speech amounts to “significant shareholder dilution” arsenic it equates to an summation successful stock count of 413%.

“The institution remains financially and operationally challenged,” Moskow suggested.

Beyond Meat president and CEO Ethan Brown had a much optimistic tone.

“We are pleased to denote this early colony of nan speech connection for our existing convertible notes, which marks a meaningful adjacent measurement towards our extremity of reducing leverage and extending indebtedness maturity for Beyond Meat,” he said successful a connection yesterday.

Investors, however, were already wary erstwhile nan indebtedness speech was revealed successful September. The shares dropped 36% to $1.82 connected 30 September, nan time of that announcement.

Challenges prevail

A displacement from $1.82 to $1.04 successful a matter of weeks must beryllium concerning for Beyond Meat and nary uncertainty marketplace watchers will beryllium eyeing consequent movements coming now nan particulate has settled connected nan indebtedness switch to immoderate degree.

Nevertheless, seen successful context, nan shares were priced astatine $25 successful May 2019 earlier nan marketplace debut for an estimated marketplace capitalisation of $1.5bn. They rallied to astir $65 connected nan first time of trading to springiness a marketplace headdress of immoderate $3.9bn, this publication reported astatine nan time.

According to calculations by Bloomberg, nan diminution successful nan shares yesterday was nan astir abrupt since station nan IPO, pinch nan news work putting nan existent marketplace headdress for Beyond Meat astatine conscionable beneath $80m.

Investors will apt now beryllium looking beyond nan debt-exchange programme, astir notably nan observations, conclusions and guidance from nan outer advisor hired in August.

John Boken astatine consultancy AlixPartners was assigned to nan job, described successful Beyond Meat’s second-quarter results filing arsenic an executive pinch “corporate turnaround and restructuring experience”.

Those results only added to nan gloom, however, has group income dropped 19.6% to $75m for nan quarter, accompanied by a nett nonaccomplishment of $29.2m. The guidance was nan aforesaid successful nan opening 3 months of nan year.

Amid each nan uncertainty, CEO Brown has resorted to not providing guidance, leaving investors successful nan acheronian complete nan forthcoming third-quarter announcement. But fixed nan grounds to date, it’s apt to return a astonishment to sound investors disconnected their perches.

That’s particularly truthful erstwhile it’s difficult to bespeak connected really Beyond Meat tin dress up nan crushed successful income erstwhile nan alternative-meat class is mostly successful decline, much truthful fixed nan company’s caller exit from China.

Even successful US retail, Beyond Meat’s largest marketplace by revenue, income were down successful nan 2nd 4th by a whopping 26.7%, though they eked retired a 6.8% summation successful foodservice.

It was a akin image successful nan world market, chiefly Europe. Sales fell 25.8% successful unit and 9.8% successful nan out-of-home channel.

John Baumgartner, a managing head astatine Mizuho Securities, summed up nan precarious trading situation for Beyond Meat successful August arsenic he commented connected nan duty of Boken.

“We position nan assignment of an interim main translator serviceman via AlixPartners arsenic a affirmative but Beyond Meat remains engaged successful a formidable hindrance betwixt needing to thrust gross maturation while expenses are reduced.

“Combined pinch economical headwinds and stronger request for animal meat, we are progressively cautious astir class maturation prospects into 2026.”